A recent recommendation from the National School Boards Association says the internet isn’t as dangerous as people think and teachers should let students use social networks at school.
The new study says fears about the internet are just overblown. Our news likes to report the very worst stories and raise our fears about the internet. And their tactics seem to work. The study says “School disctrict leaders seem to believe that negative experiences with social networking are more common than students and parents report”.
Some of the statistics from the study go a long way toward relieving our fears. For example, only 3% of students have given out their personal e-mail address, instant message screen name or personal information to strangers. Only 20% reported seeing inappropriate pictures on social networking sites in the past 3 months, and just 7% reported they had ever been bullied online or asked about their personal identity on social networking sites.
For some of the more worrisome situations, only 4% of students said they had ever had a conversation online that made them uncomfortable and only 2% said a stranger had asked to meet them. And of all 1,277 students surveyed, only one had ever met a person from the internet without their parent’s permission. That’s just 0.08%.
And yet, schools fear letting kids use any type of social networking activity.
- 84% of school districts have rules against online chatting while at school
- 81% prohibit instant messaging in school
- 62% prohibit blogging or participating in online discussion boards
- 60% have rules against sending and receiving e-mail in school
- 52% have banned any social networking site while in school
It seems schools have responded to the fear rather than the facts.
Schools also seem to be finding themselves in a bit of a double standard because districts generally say the benefits of these sites is so minimal that the risk outweighs the advantages.
Really? Well we’ve already seen the risk isn’t what we imagine it to be. But what about the advantages?
This same study, which not only surveyed students and parents but also teachers and members of school boards, revealed some very interesting findings about educators. 37% of districts report that 90% or more of their staff participated in online communities related to education! More than 90% of their staff?!? Would they be doing that if the educational advantages were minimal? Another 59% of school districts said at least half of their staff were involved in online communities. The study says “These findings indicate that educators find value in social networking and suggest that many already are comfortable and knowledgeable enough to use social networking for educational purposes with their students.”
But will they? I think they have to. And parents expect it. In the study, when parents were questioned, 76% believe that participation in social networking will improve their children’s reading and writing skills or help them express themselves more clearly. Parents also said they “expect schools to take advantage of potentially powerful educational tools, including new technology.
The study summarizes with this statement…
“Clearly both district leaders and parents are open to believing that social networking could be such a tool — as long as there are reasonable parameters of use in place. Moreover, social networking is increasingly used as a communications and collaboration tool of choice in business and higher education. As such, it would be wise for schools, whose responsibility it is to prepare students to transition to adult life with the skills they need to succeed in both arenas, to reckon with it.”
In our school, not many of our students have the skills to participate in this way. But as educators and parents, I think we have to stay aware on these issues and encourage our school and our local school boards to look at facts and not just respond to their fears.